J.J. McCarthy dynasty trade value
J.J. McCarthy (MIN) is on the Smash Accept dynasty board, valued for superflex, 1QB and TE-premium leagues.
Superflex value
4,405
12-team · PPR
1QB value
1,982
TE premium
4,405
+0.5 per rec
Overall rank
#96
QB27 of 74
J.J. McCarthy (MIN) is the QB27 on the Smash Accept dynasty board, ranked 96 overall with a superflex trade value of 4,405. That puts him in the D tier — starter / flex quarterback territory among 74 ranked quarterbacks. At 23 he has the runway that makes young quarterbacks the most expensive assets in superflex.
Value trend
7 days: +0
30 days: +1,957 (+79.9%) · up 8 at QB
90 days: +1,757
Over the last 30 days his value is up 1,957 (+79.9%), from 2,448 on 2026-10-04. That moved him up 8 spots at QB. Over 90 days he is up 1,757.
Comparable players
- RB
4,410
- WR
4,399
- TE
4,448
Value-matched trade ideas
Balanced on raw value. The calculator adds your league settings and the consolidation bonus before it grades them.
1-for-1
Give: J.J. McCarthy · 4,405
Get: Jonah Coleman · 4,410
Gap: +0.1% to the side receiving Jonah Coleman
2-for-1
Give: J.J. McCarthy · 4,405
Get: Caleb Douglass · 2,770 + 2027 4th (Late) · 1,637
Gap: 0% to the side receiving the package
Recent news
- Oct 21McCarthy will start at quarterback in Week 7, coach John Harbaugh confirmed Wednesday.
- Oct 21The Giants plan to start McCarthy at quarterback in Sunday's game against the Texans, Jeremy Fowler of ESPN.com reports.
- Oct 11McCarthy is serving as the Giants No. 2 quarterback for Sunday's game against the Commanders, Jordan Raanan of ESPN.com reports.
J.J. McCarthy in dynasty: value, format and fit
In a 1QB league he is worth 1,982, 2,423 less than in superflex — the second-quarterback slot is what makes QBs expensive. These are the numbers the dynasty trade calculator starts from; league size, scoring and consolidation logic adjust them for the trade in front of you.
The players closest to him in value are Jonah Coleman (RB, 4,410), Mike Evans (WR, 4,399) and Tucker Kraft (TE, 4,448). Inside that band, position and age decide the trade, not the raw number. A straight swap for Jonah Coleman (RB) is +0.1% for the side receiving Jonah Coleman (RB). A 2-for-1 that returns Caleb Douglass (WR) and 2027 4th (Late) is dead even on value before the consolidation bonus the calculator applies to the side getting J.J. McCarthy.
Recent news that can move his value: "McCarthy will start at quarterback in Week 7, coach John Harbaugh confirmed Wednesday." (Oct 21); "The Giants plan to start McCarthy at quarterback in Sunday's game against the Texans, Jeremy Fowler of ESPN.com reports." (Oct 21); "McCarthy is serving as the Giants No. 2 quarterback for Sunday's game against the Commanders, Jordan Raanan of ESPN.com reports." (Oct 11). Values update as the creators re-rank after news like this.
J.J. McCarthy dynasty value: questions
What is J.J. McCarthy's dynasty trade value?+
4,405 in a 12-team superflex PPR league on the Smash Accept board, where he ranks QB27 and 96 overall in the D tier.
What tier is J.J. McCarthy in?+
The D tier (starter / flex) at quarterback, based on his value as a share of the QB1's. Tiers are the useful unit in a trade: players inside one tier are close to interchangeable, and crossing a tier line is where a pick gets added.
Is J.J. McCarthy a buy or a sell right now?+
His value has risen 1,957 over the last 30 days; buyers are paying the current price, so a contender should pay it only for a clear lineup upgrade.
What is J.J. McCarthy worth in superflex vs 1QB?+
4,405 in superflex and 1,982 in 1QB. Quarterbacks carry the whole format adjustment, so the gap is the price of the second starting slot.
Who is J.J. McCarthy comparable to in dynasty value?+
Jonah Coleman (4,410), Mike Evans (4,399), Tucker Kraft (4,448) sit closest to him on the board. Players within a few percent trade roughly even; the calculator tells you which side needs a sweetener.
See J.J. McCarthy's value, rank and 90-day trend
Every player outside the top 5 at his position is part of Smash Plus ($8.99/mo): values in three formats, tier, trend, comparables and trade ideas.
Get Smash PlusAlready a member? Sign in
Price a trade with J.J. McCarthy
Opens the calculator with McCarthy already on the board — free with an account.